Other Nearby Cities: Weehawken Brooklyn New York Bronx Flushing Kew Gardens Hills Jamaica See All Cities

Bay Shore, NY

show info

Dubbed “The Heart of the South Shore,” what Bay Shore lacks in size they more than make up for in stature. As a designated hamlet of the Town of Islip in Suffolk County, Bay Shore is one of the original settlements on Long Island and is home to several historic landmarks and architecture. Times have changed since the early days, and so has this city. Even after 300 years, Main Street remains as bustling as ever, although a bit more modern.

Bay Shore Apartments

$1310-$4135

Hawthorne Court
Beds: Studio-3
Baths: 1-2

$1525-$1950

Fairfield Gardens at Bay Shore
Beds: 1-2
Baths: 1

$1660-$1975

Fairfield Country Club Gardens
Beds: 1-2
Baths: 1

$1275-$2455

Mid-Island Apartments
Beds: Studio-2
Baths: 1-1.5

$1280-$1850

Fairfield At East Islip
Beds: Studio-2
Baths: 1-2

$1495-$1925

Fairfield Eastbrook Gardens
Beds: 1-2
Baths: 1

Key City Stats

The average age of Bay Shore, NY is
45 to 49
explore info on residents
hide
  • Age Demographic of Renters
  • 25 to 29 years
  • 30 to 34 years
  • 35 to 39 years
  • Male
  • 7.54%
  • 5.72%
  • 7.12%
  • Female
  • 7.34%
  • 6.45%
  • 6.33%
$1271
is average rent in Bay Shore, NY
Explore info on rent prices
hide
  • Rent Range
  • $650 to $699
  • $700 to $749
  • $750 to $799
  • Percentage of household units
  • 1.02%
  • 0.85%
  • 0.0%
27.0%
of units are available for rent in Bay Shore
Explore info on housing
hide
  • Vacancy Status
  • For Rent
  • Rented, not occupied
  • Other vacant
  • Housing Units
  • 165
  • 28
  • 171
Getting Around in Bay Shore, NY

12
Walk Score®
"Car-Dependent"
N/A
Transit Score®
N/A
The average commuter time in Bay Shore is:
10 to 14 minutes
Explore info about this city
hide
  • Time Range
  • 25 to 29 minutes
  • 30 to 34 minutes
  • 35 to 39 minutes
  • Percentage of workers
  • 4.72%
  • 13.18%
  • 1.29%

Sagtikos Manor

One of the oldest and most well-known pieces of historic architecture lies at the heart of the town in the form of Sagtikos Manor. Built in 1697 for its original purpose as headquarters of the British army during the Revolutionary War, it has since been converted into a living museum with costumed tour guides and period correct furnishings on the inside. It’s a great way to get a little piece of history and see what life in colonial America was like. Even George Washington himself was a resident for a bit during his tour of Long Island in 1790. If it’s good enough for the first president, it’s worth a look for you.

Bay Shore YMCA

When you think of fitness and access to quality facilities, the YMCA is a good place to start. A former local theatre and opera house in Bay Shore has been renovated and expanded into a massive complex that houses a gym, pool, track, and weight room. They even have after-school programs for kids, where they can work on school assignments and mingle with other children while mom and dad are still at the office. The Boulton Center for the Performing Arts, also part of the YMCA, offers a number of concerts, dance classes, film showings, poetry, and play readings.