Bay Shore Apartments for Rent
Search Apartments in Bay Shore
"You make this whole apartment searching process a lot easier. The way your site is set up helps me search and contact places to find the information I need to make my decision." - Bay Shore,NY
Popular Bay Shore Apartments

Mid-Island Apartments
Bay Shore, New York, 11706
Studio/1 Bedroom$1,145 - $1,535
2 Bedrooms$1,710 - $1,905
MyNewPlace Apartment Finder Features
- Floor Plans
- Photos
- Interactive Maps
- Videos
Bay Shore Apartments Info
Find Apartments in Bay Shore, New York
Finding a beautiful new apartment in Bay Shore is a piece of cake, it doesn't matter what price range you are looking in, Bay Shore has the perfect new apartment for you.
Want the inside scoop on Bay Shore? Check out our Bay Shore Local Talk for local tips and information about Bay Shore. You can also get answers to your Bay Shore questions from our local experts by using the "Ask a Question" feature.
"Land Ho!
There’s nothing like the beauty of the Great South Bay. Bay Shore, New York, may be just a hop, skip, and a jump from New York City, but it's a world away from the busy streets and crowded cafes of the Big Apple. Bay Shore is a hamlet with a population of around 20,000 people. There are lots people around to make friends with but not so many people that you'll feel lost in the crowd. Of course, if you want to get lost in the crowd from time to time, New York City is right there, ready and waiting to provide endless entertainment and plenty of people en masse!
If you're thinking about renting an apartment in Bay Shore, head over to our Apartment Guide before you start searching for a great new place. At the Apartment Guide, you can pick up lots of tips that will make it easier to find that ever-elusive perfect pad. If you're in need of more information about Bay Shore, visit the LocalTalk and get in touch with some of the people who already call this town home. It's the perfect way to get the inside scoop on Bay Shore without having to leave the comfort of your chair!" "Apartment Rental Rates
Whether you're looking for a sleek one bedroom apartment downtown or a spacious three bedroom place with a view of the park, we're here to help you find it. If you're wondering how much you can expect to spend on an apartment in Bay Shore, all you have to do is take a look at our rent chart. It has all the information on the latest average rates. Though apartments can be a bit pricy here, you do get what you pay for, and in Bay City, you get a fabulous hometown with easy access to New York City. Ready to learn more about what it's like to live in this great town? Read on! Once you've decided that Bay Shore is the place for you, start your search for a great new place by reading through the apartment rental listings below." "A Hamlet by Any Other Name
Back before European explorers arrived in North America, the area around Bay Shore was known as Awixa, a Secatogue word that means, ""where the stream ends."" The first European settlers called the area Penataquit, after another Native American word, but the name was soon changed to Sodom, despite the fact that this biblical city was burned to the ground in a hail of brimstone. Deciding that Sodom wasn't, in fact, a good name for a lovely hamlet, in 1842 the hamlet's residents again called for a name change, this time settling on Mechanicsville. Industry flourished in Mechanicsville for many years before the name was finally changed one last time, this time to Bay Shore. Today, Bay Shore is a hamlet within the town of Islip, in Suffolk County. Whatever you call it, Bay Shore is a great place to call home.
Bay Shore Is on Fire
Bay Shore is on a part of Long Island that has flourished as a tourist destination since the mid-1800s. Then, as now, the area was known for its beautiful scenery and easy access to Fire Island. People still come to Bay Shore from all over New England in order to vacation in town and the get away from it all on the island. If you're a fan of the great outdoors, you'll be happy to learn that you can enjoy easy access to the island by way of a ferry that runs year-round. On the island, you'll find sandy beaches, shops up the wazoo, resort hotels, and opportunities for hiking, camping, fishing, and wildlife watching. What a great way to spend the weekend–and when you live in Bay Shore, you can visit this paradise any time you'd like.
Some of the Best Ribs You’ll Ever Eat
If you're hoping to taste some of the best barbecue you’ll ever eat, Bay Shore has you covered. Smokin Al’s Famous BBQ Joint serves up all kinds of good eats right in town. Tantalize your tongue with some of the best barbecue sauces you’ll ever have and don't be afraid to lick your plate–and your fingers–clean.
Calling All History Buffs
Are you into local history? Bay Shore has plenty of historic buildings and sites to see and explore. Many of the area's Victorian homes and estates are still standing, and though many are private residences (some of which have been converted into apartments), it is possible to tour a few of them. Head out from Bay Shore a few miles and you'll find plenty more historic sites as well as a number of museums. Learn more about Bay Shore's fascinating history by exploring the town and getting in touch with the Suffolk County Historical Society. If you're lucky, you may even be able to move into one of the hamlet's historic apartments. What a way to live!"
Average Apartment Rent in Bay Shore, New York
| # Bedrooms | Apr | Jan | Dec | 3 Month % change |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studio | $1,190 | $1,249 | $1,249 | -4.7% |
| 1 Bed | $1,424 | $1,407 | $1,425 | -0.1% |
| 2 Bed | $1,813 | $1,789 | $1,794 | 1.1% |
| 3 Bed | N/A | N/A | N/A | 0% |
Bay Shore Apartment Rental Trends
Apartments in Bay Shore have competitive rents so be sure to use our apartment finder to get the best deal. In December the average rent for a 1 Bedroom Bay Shore apartment cost $1,425. If you need a roommate, try finding a 2 bedroom apartment rental. An average 2 bedroom Bay Shore apartment was $1,794 in December. Start your apartment search by checking out some of the Bay Shore rentals listed below.Popular Bay Shore Apartments Searches
Check out our most popular searches for apartments for rent in Bay Shore, NY
- Furnished Bay Shore Apartments
- Pet-friendly Bay Shore Apartments
- Studio Bay Shore Apartments
- One Bedroom Bay Shore Apartments
- Two Bedroom Bay Shore Apartments
- Three Bedroom Bay Shore Apartments
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $500
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $600
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $700
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $800
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $900
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $1000
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $1200
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $1500
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $2000
- Bay Shore Apartments Under $2500
- Bay Shore Apartments with Laundry
- Bay Shore Apartments with Short Term Lease
Rent Apartments Near Bay Shore, New York
Check out these great communities and cities near Bay Shore for apartments for rent:
Map & Local Information
Local Talk
Get answers about Bay Shore from local experts or tell us what you love about it.
-
I'm relocating. What's the weather like in Bay Shore?
There are 4 seasons in Bay Shore, including warm summers, very cold winters, and relatively mild springs and autumns. Summer temperatures tend to be in the 70s and winter temperatures tend to be in the 30s. The average high temperature in July, the warmest month of the year, is 83 degrees Fahrenheit, while the average low temperature in January, the coldest month of the year, is 23 degrees Fahrenheit. On average Bay Shore receives 47 inches of precipitation annually. Rainfall is fairly evenly distributed throughout the year, although March tends to be the wettest month.


